Features
RSS Feed
Time to address D2C content abuses
Sally Weatherall, chair, AIME
Jul 1
Regulation targeted at dodgy D2C practices needs a re-think if the industry is to re-build consumer trust.
A few weeks ago ME focused on the problems associated with regional D2C content markets by highlighting the class action settlement against AT&T Wireless in the US for unauthorised charges from third party ringtone providers. It came in the context of rising complaints registered to the UK regulator PhonePayPlus (formerly ICSTIS).
Over the years, PhonePayPlus has levied more and more restrictions on how D2C service providers can reach users – and there could be more on the way. But at the same time many within the industry are pushing for more appropriate forms of self-regulation. These measures would allow the UK market to flourish once again, eliminating dodgy content providers by making them directly accountable to the regulators.
Under the current PhonePayPlus Code of Practice, primary liability rests with the service provider/aggregator rather than the content provider – even though it’s the latter that has control over the marketing of its services. As long as this situation remains, there is no incentive on the content provider to comply with the code. They can simply default on the fine, move to a different aggregator and leave the former UK aggregator to pay the fine, carry the bad debt and suffer reputation damage.
This is not effective regulation, it provides no consumer protection as the service continues and undermines the authority of the regulator. What criminal would worry about being in court if they knew their mate waiting outside would be the one serving the sentence?
Instead, the Association of Interactive Media and Entertainment (AIME) is advocating a content provider’s registration scheme, a review on the ban on third party databases, consistency in the implementation of PayforIt, and more action by publishers to refuse non-compliant advertising
Regulation should bite at the point of sale, not the technology intermediary. Such a scheme of registration could easily be developed to provide a Kite mark of credibility, which would be a guide to both consumers and service providers.
In addition, PhonePayPlus is advocating a total ban on the use of third party databases due to the inability, under Data Protection legislation, of obtaining informed consumer consent by way of pre-ticked consent boxes. In practice, it is difficult to envisage where informed consent can be properly achieved in regard to traded databases. AIME believes it would be fairer to the consumer to use databases where consumers have directly opted in – consumers could be sent a free marketing message providing the new service information and expressly seeking consumer consent to receive such content. If the consumer does not respond to that message then the details should not be used. Such a system would improve transparency and result in direct opt-in information in every case.
Then there’s payment. More and more content services are using PayforIt so all operators need to be consistent if the channel is to be nationally supported and perceived as a genuine tool of consumer protection.
Finally, publishers themselves need to take action by refusing to take non-compliant advertising. Publishers already have a responsibility to ensure advertising complies with relevant laws and regulations. They take the same stance when it does not comply with the PPP Code of Practice.
If these initiatives (or even some of them) were adopted widely by the industry and the regulator, the cycle of ‘growth, regulation and collapse’ of mobile D2C content markets around the world could be prevented and consumer trust in such services restored.
Other Features
- How to make flat rate music work on mobile
Jul 02
- Operator's best hope for service revenue? Real-time billing
Jul 02
- Let’s talk about money. Making money.
Jun 22
- The GPU: not just for gaming
Jun 08
- MOBILE GAMES FOCUS, PART 2: The app store 'PlayStation effect'
May 26
- MOBILE GAMES FOCUS, PART 1: EA Q&A
May 22
- Mobile video - Unreel expectations?
May 11
- Ovi and out
Apr 30
- SECTOR PROFILE: Music ID services
Apr 21
- Jingle all the wait
Apr 14
- SECTOR PROFILE: Porn in the USA
Apr 09
- ROUNDTABLE: Can app stores only work for Apple?
Apr 07
- Read all about it – how newspapers can survive the digital transition
Mar 30
- Using female intuition at male-dominated trade shows
Mar 24
- COUNTRY PROFILE: Brazil
Mar 23
- INTERVIEW: Richard Titus, Controller of Future Media, BBC
Mar 10
- Making money from nothing
Mar 10
- SECTOR PROFILE: Mobile barcodes & quick response
Mar 09
- Data services will save mobile from the downturn
Feb 26
- Can mobile learn to trawl?
Feb 24
- What can mobile learn from Wii and DS?
Feb 20
- Brands + mobile social networks = marketing bliss?
Feb 18
- INTERVIEW: Vringo talks video ringtones
Feb 11
- Look who's poking now
Feb 09
- One data price fits all?
Feb 06
- GAME DEVELOPER SPECIAL: Part Five
Jan 27
- GAME DEVELOPER SPECIAL: Part Four
Jan 26
- GAME DEVELOPER SPECIAL: Part Three
Jan 23
- GAME DEVELOPER SPECIAL: Part Two
Jan 22
- PhonepayPlus: Why we had to act against rogue traders
Jan 22
- GAME DEVELOPER SPECIAL: Part One
Jan 21
- BlackBerry content - A Bold opportunity?
Jan 15
- What's in store for 3D Java graphics?
Jan 09
- ROUNDTABLE: The future of mobile advertising
Jan 07
- The ME news review of 2008
Jan 06
- Is the future idle screen?
Dec 11
- How to make mobile broadband profitable
Dec 10
- Why mobile ads need their own vocabulary
Dec 02
- INTERVIEW: Pete Russell - MD, Player One
Nov 28
- SECTOR PROFILE: Ringback tones
Nov 26
- Preparing for the digital future
Nov 24
- INTERVIEW: Mike Johns - CEO, Urban World Wireless
Nov 24
- COUNTRY PROFILE: Israel
Nov 13
- Is mobile video moving yet?
Nov 10
- MobiTV's European re-transmission
Nov 06
- Mobile social networks - boom times ahead?
Oct 28
- Can football clubs score with mobile content?
Oct 23
- COUNTRY PROFILE: South Africa
Oct 20
- The Verizon text affair: MEF responds
Oct 16
- Sleeping giants rise to iPhone challenge
Oct 16
- The killer app is dead. Long live the killer service
Oct 13
- iPhone development: The new goldrush
Oct 08
- Analysing the Nokia 5800
Oct 07
- INTERVIEW: Barry Houlihan - Managing Director, MIG
Oct 06
- INTERVIEW: Steve Ricketts - Head of Third Party Services, Orange
Sep 30
- Mobile advertising - sender pays?
Sep 18
- INTERVIEW: Tony Pearce - CEO, Player X
Sep 17
- Crunch time looming for mobile broadband?
Sep 16
- My vision for an Omni Media future
Sep 12
- Top 50 US execs
Sep 12
- New rules of thumb
Sep 02
- The future of WAP billing
Aug 22
- Projector phones: A vision of the future?
Aug 18
- The Pocket Internet: What does it mean for mobile content?
Jul 30
- Ringtone rip-offs: Where does D2C go now?
Jul 29
- The future of mobile advertising, Part Three
Jul 28
- The future of mobile advertising, Part Two
Jul 14
- The future of mobile advertising, Part One
Jul 10
- ME's Top 50 women in mobile content
Jul 04
- What are the implications of the Symbian Foundation?
Jun 24
- Interview: Lewis McDonald talks to ME
Jun 23
- ROUNDTABLE: One year on, what has been iPhone's impact?
Jun 10
- The ultimate entertainment handset?
Jun 03
- How to unleash developer creativity on the mobile web
May 28
- How Guitar Hero went mobile
May 23
- Do mobile consumers have too much choice?
May 15
- How can we improve mobile user experience?
May 12
- The times of India
May 07
- Mobile content - experience urgently required
May 06
- Let's make mobile games pricing more flexible
May 06
- Why we launched CasualGaming.biz
May 01
- What do mobile games and Phil Collins have in common?
Apr 28
- The best tool for promoting content? Social networks
Apr 21
- How sharing could be the key to better ARPU
Apr 17
- Getting the market ready for video
Apr 11
- Why is mobile content a magnet for venture capital?
Apr 08
- Motorola brand - which way now?
Mar 27
- US spectrum auction - the winners and losers
Mar 26
- For better adult mobile sales, think Tesco
Mar 20
- What does the EC's decision to endorse DVB-H really mean?
Mar 18
- Does the British mobile content industry punch above its weight?
Mar 16
- Mobile advertising: the opportunity and the danger
Mar 10
- Can mobile boost the big social networks?
Mar 06
- Defining the mobile user experience
Mar 03
- Can C++ save mobile gaming?
Feb 25
- The secrets of a mobile games localiser...
Feb 18
- INTERVIEW: Javier Pérez Dolset - CEO, Zed
Feb 08
- INTERVIEW: Luca Pagano - UK MD, Buongiorno
Feb 07
- The mobile video paradox
Feb 05
- Microsoft/Yahoo: mobile could be the icing on the cake
Feb 04
- Outsourcing games portals - good news for all
Feb 01
- How to succeed with sideloading
Jan 25
- Mobile Video - it's all about the UE
Jan 22
- INTERVIEW: Anssi Vanjoki - EVP of multimedia, Nokia
Jan 18
- What are you on? About.
Jan 14
- What lies ahead in 2008?
Jan 09
- Let messaging drive the mobile internet
Dec 18
- The truth about transcoding
Dec 05
- Some ancient wisdom from carriers, please?
Nov 08
- What happened to the Chinese D2C market?
Nov 08
- What's Google's real agenda?
Nov 05
- Mobile advertising’s lack of transparency
Nov 01
- Which way for US now?
Oct 19
- INTERVIEW: Javier Perez Dolset - CEO, Zed
Oct 17
- No show at the showcase
Sep 06
- COUNTRY PROFILE: Nigeria
Sep 06
- The challenges of the UK content market
Sep 06
- INTERVIEW: Peter Mercier - Head of Mobile, BBC Worldwide
Sep 06
- Where are we going?
Sep 06
- Adult ready to grow up
Sep 06
- All to pay for
Sep 06
- INTERVIEW: Anthony Douglas - Head of Games, O2
Aug 09
- Have it your way
Aug 09
- Location aware
Aug 09
- INTERVIEW: Ashu Mathura
Aug 09
- Embedded advertising
Jul 05
- How to improve your mobile website
Jul 05
- INTERVIEW: Gautum Sabharwal
Jul 05
- Jamba grows up
Jul 05
















